2010 - NYR - D Dylan McIlrath - Moose Jaw (WHL)
2009 - EDM - LW Magnus Paajarvi - Timra (Sweden)
2008 - VAN - C Cody Hodgson - Brampton (OHL)
2007 - FLA - D Keaton Ellerby - Kamloops (WHL)
2006 - FLA - Michael Frolik - Kladno (Czech)
2005 - VAN - D Luc Bourdon - Val-d'Or (QMJHL)
2004 - ATL - D Boris Valabik - Kitchener (OHL)
2003 - MTL - RW Andrei Kostitsyn - CSKA Moscow (Russia)
2002 - CGY - LW Eric Nystrom - Michigan (CCHA)
2001 - NYR - G Dan Blackburn - Kootenay (WHL)
2000 - CHI - C Mikhail Yakubov - Tolyatti-2 (Russia)
1999 - NYI - D Branislav Mezei - Belleville Bulls (OHL)
1998 - TOR - C Nik Antropov - Torpedo UST-Kamengorsk (Russia)
1997 - VAN - D Brad Ference - Spokane (WHL)
1996 - NJD - D Lance Ward - Red Deer (WHL)
1995 - FLA - RW Radek Dvorak - Ceske Budejovice HC (Czech)*
1994 - WSH - D Nolan Baumgartner - Kamloops (WHL)
1993 - QUE - G Jocelyn Thibault - Sherbrooke (QMJHL)
1992 - SJS - LW Andrei Nazarov - Moscow Dynamo (Russia)
1991 - DET - RW Martin Lapointe - Laval (QMJHL)

*Dvorak did not spend his entire career in Florida, but returned to the team from 2007 to 2011. He was traded to Atlanta in 2011.